In one of the most hilariously memorable and musically unique auditions in America’s Got Talent history, the boyband The Other Direction presented themselves as the world’s “gayest boy band,” ready to take on the likes of One Direction. The video, titled “The Other Direction: World’s ‘Gayest’ Boyband Ready To Take Over ONE DIRECTION!,” captured their high-energy, tongue-in-cheek debut that blended sharp comedy with surprising vocal talent.
The group of five introduced themselves with distinct personas: Alex the Jock, Norm the Cowboy, Jason the Party Boy, Greg the Mama Bear, and Devin the Fashionista . They shared a heartwarming backstory, explaining that they met in middle school at show choir camp and all came out to each other there . They made a pact to form the band when they turned 21, fulfilling a “destiny” to be the new force in music .
For their audition, The Other Direction performed an original song titled “Girl, You’re the Best.” The song was a brilliant piece of musical comedy, featuring lyrics that hilariously subverted boyband tropes, such as, “I can paint your toenails in the hot tub” and wondering why the narrator is “allowed to hang out in your room with the door closed” .
Despite the humor, the performance showcased genuine musicality, with the group demonstrating tight harmonies and strong vocal execution. Their stage presence was magnetic and funny, keeping the judges and the audience completely engaged from beginning to end. Heidi Klum was immediately charmed, proclaiming, “I don’t want you to stop!” .
The judges’ feedback was overwhelmingly positive. Howie Mandel and Sofia Vergara both praised the group for being “really funny, really talented” and called the song “amazing,” with great voices . Simon Cowell added a high compliment, noting that while he had auditioned many terrible boy bands, this was “different,” “very clever,” and a “well-written song”
Ultimately, The Other Direction won over the panel with their originality, securing four enthusiastic yeses and moving on in the competition. Their combination of sharp wit and solid musical talent proved that they were a true entertainment package. The performance remains a celebrated viral moment for its bold concept and hilarious execution. You can watch their full, legendary audition here:
