Thirteen-year-old Chase Varnes, a self-taught guitarist and drummer from a farm, arrived on the America’s Got Talent (AGT) stage with the ultimate dream: to perform on a world stage and “make people happy.” Accompanied by his supportive parents, Chase had the look of a pop star, which the judges immediately noted. For his audition, he began singing a heartfelt song, but the moment was quickly derailed. A tense silence fell over the arena when Simon Cowell abruptly stopped the performance mid-song. Simon confessed that while he liked Chase, he did not “love the song,” putting the young singer in the high-pressure situation of needing a second chance.
Facing the immense stress of a live television audience and a critical panel, Chase bravely took the stage again. For his second attempt, he performed a passionate cover of “Life Goes On” by Ed Sheeran. This time, his voice was stronger, his guitar playing more confident, and his emotional delivery much clearer. The song—about the pain of loss and the resilience required to move forward—connected instantly with the audience. His improved performance was a remarkable demonstration of emotional resilience and his ability to adapt under pressure, immediately winning over a captivated audience.
The judges had mixed but ultimately positive feedback. Sofia Vergara told Chase that the second song was definitely better, while Heidi Klum compared him to a “young Justin Bieber.” Howie Mandel was the only judge to say “no,” advising Chase to return in a year once he had more confidence. However, the final vote came down to Simon Cowell. Despite his initial harsh criticism, Simon was genuinely impressed, admitting he believed Chase had real talent and a clear love for music. Chase’s comeback earned him three “yeses” and secured his spot in the next round, confirming that the pressure of a second chance had ultimately brought out the star within him.
